|#351674 Author: Deepak Malik Member Level: Silver Member Rank: 1491 Date: 13/Sep/2012 Rating: Points: 2|
Yes, looking at the statistics you can say so. But i dont think it's fair to compare two individuals in any field. these both have their own way of batting and their own technique. So, the most matters in cricket is form. And both of them are in superb form.
|#351680 Author: Chitra Member Level: Diamond Member Rank: 26 Date: 13/Sep/2012 Rating: Points: 1|
Yes, as Deepak said from the above details we can conclude that Hashim Amla is better. But Virat Koli is one of my favorite players.
"Do not give up, things might not favour you always"
|#351694 Author: Ankur Garg Member Level: Gold Member Rank: 246 Date: 13/Sep/2012 Rating: Points: 5|
As per my opinion both are wonderful and rising players. It would not be right to disregard anyone on the basis of statistics as both players have different skills, techniques and attitude. Personally I feel that Hashim Amal is much strong as far as technique is concerned whereas Virat is still need to work on his technique. Because scoring good runs in International cricket is not enough and at a certain point of time you need to display you batting technique especially when you are playing in foreign countries like Australia, New Zealand and South Africa.
Further Virat has played some wonderful innings to ensure the victory of India so as a player we all love him. His enthusiasm and ability to score quickly is simply wonderful. Slowly and steadily he has established himself as a dangerous batsman for the opponent team. I would wish both Amal and Kohli to played well for their teams.
Company Secretary and Compliance Officer
|#351698 Author: Deepak Malik Member Level: Silver Member Rank: 1491 Date: 13/Sep/2012 Rating: Points: 1|
Amla is 29 years, 155 days.
Kohli is 23 years, 302 days.
Almost 6 years younger.
|#351706 Author: Nithin Member Level: Gold Member Rank: 616 Date: 13/Sep/2012 Rating: Points: 4|
Amla is 29 and kohli is just 22. Amla debuted to the international scene in 2004 where Kohli was only palying his u-15 matches. So one advantage with Amla was experience in his side. Amla's record is only good when SA is winning . Kohli mean while has better even when the team is loosing. Kohli started his career as an opening batsman. Then had to bat at 5,6&7. Only in 2010-11 he again came into the top 4. So by the time Kohli will be 29 he will be having better stats than Amla considering the given form he is in.
|#351755 Author: swapnil Member Level: Bronze Member Rank: 12180 Date: 13/Sep/2012 Rating: Points: 1|
If you compare to age and killing attitude for all format of games,Virat Kohli is better than Hashim Amla.
|#351758 Author: Pradeepraj R Member Level: Gold Member Rank: 252 Date: 13/Sep/2012 Rating: Points: 4|
My opinion is that Kohli is better than Amla. Kohli playing very well from the under 19 itself. He was the captain when India won the under 19 world cup for the second. Kohli centuries are worthful coming in the critical matches. He played in the Australian ground to make quick century to chase three hundred plus runs in less than fourty overs. He is the man of cricket. He played the best bowler Malinga who often bowl yorkerr. He player casually in his bowling. The matches are only in sub continent. Though he played there in England and Australia where he played for the first time. There should be some time to learn. His shot selection and face of the bat are good showing he is a great batsman. Amla is also good in cricket. But Kohli is equally good to him.
|#351760 Author: Sudhan Member Level: Gold Member Rank: 262 Date: 13/Sep/2012 Rating: Points: 4|
I think that the players are class batsmen who are known for turning the games on there way. They are specialized strikers of ball who can place the ball well. It is absolutely difficult to determine who is the best but as of the time and comparison I think that Amla has the edge as of now over Kohli. But the things would change definitely in the future where the Indian cricketer would prove himself to be the best in the cricketing world. His unique style, rotating the ball and consistency has made him the best among the Indian players as of now. He is performing well in almost all the series in the recent times and his rank is going up and up in the recent period. Hope he gets to the top of the rankings soon after replacing Amla in the ODI rankings.
"The greatest achievement comes from the biggest challenges"
|#351838 Author: dipesh kumar agrawal Member Level: Bronze Member Rank: 3714 Date: 13/Sep/2012 Rating: Points: 1|
thought amla is a senior player and has much more experience than kholi,there is no doubt that at present VIRAT KHOLI is a better ODI player :)
|#352524 Author: anshuman rampal Member Level: Bronze Member Rank: 0 Date: 15/Sep/2012 Rating: Points: 3|
This is a very interesting question actually and i want to share that Hashim Amla is my fav. player, not from now, but from the time when S.A came to india and lost the matches 3-4 years ago. I think he is a far better player than virat kohli.
In my opinion, Kohli plays selfishly,he doesnt bother whether his team is on winning position or losing position, he just plays for his runs without taking risks. Moreover, he cant even play express fast bowlers properly. :)
|#352784 Author: Rajneesh Gupta Member Level: Gold Member Rank: 506 Date: 16/Sep/2012 Rating: Points: 5|
Hashim amla and Virat kohli both are good players and have done a huge contribution for their respective teams. According to me both are best players and there is no comparison between them. Here are my some views about both of them.
This 29 years old opener of South Africa is this time the best batsman in ODI rankings with 871 ODI ratings. Starting his career in 2008, he first time got rank one in ODI cricket in 2010. From last two years his performance is very consistent. He has scored 2 centuries in 2012 yet, one against Sri-Lanka in Paarl(SA) and another against England in Southampton(ENG). He also owns the records of fastest man reaching 2000 runs in ODI in 40 innings and reaching 3000 runs in ODI in 59 innings.
There is no introduction needed for this young star from India. The vice captain of India Virat Kohli is this time the 2nd ranked top ten ODI batsman with 858 points. The number of centuries he scored in 2012 yet is 5. He is performing consistently in every format of cricket whether it is ODI, Test or T-20. His last 3 centuries include 1 against Sri-Lanka and 2 in asia cup against Pakistan and Bangladesh. The most thriller and outstanding was against Pakistan where he scored 183 off only 148 balls.