You must Sign In to post a response.
  • Category: Requests

    WHy my job post got rejected?

    Yesterday I tried to post a Job vacancy I found on Facebook. It was a vacancy for a tutor in a local institute based in Kerala. But unfortunately, the job post was rejected saying that it's in proper. I would like to know the exact reason for this so that I can get my future job posts approved. Here is the link to my rejected post -
    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/456212-presidency-the-professional-tutors-are-looking-for-tutors-in-video-editing
    Please guide me..
  • #714997
    Narendra, the reason for rejecting your job post was because it was improper. Please read and understand this thread on how to submit job posts and also this thread which provides the guidelines for posting job posts. You need to not only understand the requirements but also must follow them strictly.

    A point I would like to mention here is that, had you heeded to our advice in your thread announcing your return to ISC to read and understand all the guidelines so that you are aware of the changes that have come up, you may not have had to raise this thread.

    'Knowledge is knowing what to say. Wisdom is knowing when to say it.' -Anonymous

  • #715001
    Thank you for your reply. It's my mistake that I did not read the guidelines, well. One thing I want to know is that is the jobs Facebook Jobs allowed here?

  • #715012
    @Saji Ganesh:

    My posts were also rejected for strange reasons. As you know that we have to provide the link of the source from which we have come to know about this job. This link of the source is not displayed on the board.
    My first 3/4 posts were approved and the source of job information/notification was a Job Portal. then I continued the same source in other posts also because the posts were already approved with the same source but the editor rejected further posts saying that job portals are not permitted. Then, why did he approve other posts?
    Then I saw which sources are allowed in other approved posts and I found newspapers like Deccan Chronicle, Hindustan Times etc. Then I posted a job post and the source was Employment news. I think you know about this government job newspaper but he rejected saying that Job portals are not permitted. It was a weird reason. Private newspapers are permitted but government job newspapers are not permitted.

    Then I posted a few job posts and the source was Amar Ujala (Hindi newspaper) and all the posts were approved but the further same source was rejected saying that Non-English language source is not permitted. Then, Why did he approve other posts?

    Whoever is the editor of Job section I think he needs to be given proper training. An intelligent editor never do such mistakes.

    Now I have not posted any job post after it.

  • #715032
    Arafatuzzafar, you should have raised a thread about the issues as and when you faced it. I do not understand what made you wait for so long. Anyways, we can check out with the panel editors if you can provide the URLs of the posts you are referring to.
    'Knowledge is knowing what to say. Wisdom is knowing when to say it.' -Anonymous

  • #715054
    Sir, plz see following links.

    1: Central Railway recruitment for Medical Practitioners, Retired Doctors in Mumbai
    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455184-central-railway-recruitment-for-medical-practitioners-retird-doctors-in-mumbai

    Rejected: Reason: job portal is not permitted.

    2: Central Coalfields Ltd is looking for Trade Apprentice in Ranchi
    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455069-ccl-is-looking-for-trade-apprentice-in-ranchi

    Approved: source- the same job portal (as above)

    3: Bombay High Court Recruitment for the post of Senior System Officer & System Officer
    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455528-bombay-high-court-receuitment-for-senior-system-officer-system-officer

    Rejected: Reason- contents taken from Hindi Source. (Daily Amar Ujala)

    4: BMHRC Recruitment for Contractual Scientist-B (Medical) in Bhopal
    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455465-bmhrc-recruitment-for-contractual-scientist-b-medical-in-bhopal

    Approved: Source of contents is Hindi (Daily Amar Ujala)

    5: Mother Athena School Badaun recruitment for PGT-Accountancy
    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455518-mother-athena-school-badaun-recruitment-for-pgt-accountancy

    Rejected: Reason - source of contents is Hindi (Amar Ujala)

  • #715099
    @Saji Ganesh
    Sir, Anyways I have gone through guidelines and edited my Job Post. For resubmitting I just need to click on submit button. Am I right...If not please tell me how to resubmit. Hopes this edit will make my job post okay.

  • #715379
    Narendran, sorry for the delay in responding to your query. I suggest you submit a fresh entry in case the post is still open. Please ensure that you give all the required details. Also, do check whether the opening has been reported elsewhere. You need to confirm the authenticity of the vacancy as also the advertiser. The guidelines do make it amply clear that you must post only such jobs that are posted in the company/ institute's official website. So, even if you come across an advertisement in any other portal, you need to check with the official website before posting the same here.

    Arafatuzzafar, points noted. We will discuss it and get back to you.

    'Knowledge is knowing what to say. Wisdom is knowing when to say it.' -Anonymous

  • #715383
    Job post may get rejected for some reason. I suggest you need to analyse what peoples is posting in job section. Carefully read all and what type of job post they are posting.

    One step ahead see the ranking of your job post on SERP. So, that you will know what ranks and why.

  • #715409
    @Narendran,
    Best way to not to get our posts rejected by editors is to go through the posting guidelines made separately for all the sections and understand the same further it is also advisable to go through some of the approved job posts before making a job post.

    Contents taken from other job portals, from social media s by giving links to social media websites or to job portals, insufficient content in the job post and for other various reasons a job post will be rejected.

    Review of enormous posts in a day by editors may very rarely approve posts which are not according to the guidelines but later it will be rectified by rejecting such pre-approved posts.

    In your case the contents for the job post is taken from Facebook and the contents provided were insufficient hence it was rejected. Kindly go through the guidelines properly and check some of the approved job posts before making next job post.

    @Arafatuzzafar,
    In your first job post you have provided link to other job portal which is a recruitment job news portal it is against the guidelines hence it was rejected whereas in the second post you have provided the official link in PDF format hence it was approved.

    The official notifications should be in English if not job posts with links to other than English language will not be approved this is the guideline of ISC Admin.

  • #715953
    Arafatuzzafar, has your query been answered? Please confirm.
    'Knowledge is knowing what to say. Wisdom is knowing when to say it.' -Anonymous

  • #715968
    @Ravi Shankar: No, you are still running away from confessing your mistakes.

    First, you have not clarified both issues I raised.

    1: You said," In your first job post you have provided link to other job portal which is a recruitment job news portal it is against the guidelines hence it was rejected whereas in the second post you have provided the official link in PDF format hence it was approved."

    - No, you are wrong. first it is the matter of job portal whether official notification is given or not, should be rejected. It's against rule to approve one post and reject another post of the same job portal.
    I gave the links of official notification / pdf in all my posts. Plz see all my posts whether notification link is there or not.
    Note: In one post -pertaining to Mother Athena there is no pdf notification by school.

    Following is my first job post which you approved. Pl see source of information is the same job portal. Why did you approve it?

    Delhi Police department is looking for constable (executive)
    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/454948-delhi-police-department-is-looking-for-constable-executive

    Some of the posts you rejected for abovesaid reason. Pls note that all these job posts have direct links to official job notifications.
    Hope you will not do it with other users.

    Bombay High Court Recruitment for the post of Senior System Officer & System Officer

    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455528-bombay-high-court-receuitment-for-senior-system-officer-system-officer

    AIASL Mumbai is looking for Para Medical Agent Cum Cabin Service Agent & more

    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455319-aiasl-is-looking-for-para-medical-agent-cum-cabin-service-agent-more-in

    GPSC Recruitment for Lecturers, Senior Psychiatrist and more

    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455197-gpsc-recruitment-for-lecturers-senior-psychiatrist-and-more

    DLSA Dhenkanal recruitment for the post of Jr Clerk/Jr Clerk-cum-Typist

    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455168-dlsa-dhenkanal-recruitment-for-the-post-of-jr-clerk-jr-clerk-cum-typist

    DH&FWS Cooch Behar recruitment for various posts under NHM & NUHM

    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455139-dh-fws-cooch-behar-recruitment-for-various-posts-under-nhm-nuhm

    2: You said, "The official notifications should be in English if not job posts with links to other than English language will not be approved this is the guideline of ISC Admin."

    - No, you are wrong. I didn't raise the issue of language of the notification, rather , it was the issue of language of source of job (Hindi newspaper Amar uajala). one post was approved and another was rejected of the same newspaper.

    Moreover, you are still diverting the issue.
    If the notification in Hindi is not acceptable then why following job post was approved of which notification (pdf) was in Hindi

    Professional Examination Board Bhopal vacancy for Sub Engineers through examination 2020

    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455486-peb-bhopal-recruitment-for-sub-engineer

    It is my advice to you please let other members come in the job section. Plz, don't discourage them by rejecting their post.

    I hope that you will be a good editor in future.

  • #716038
    Mistakes do happen when bulk posts reviewed, this has been repeated often.

    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/454948-delhi-police-department-is-looking-for-constable-executive
    The above job post should have been kept in pending as the source is not provided correctly yet retained as it is already approved except with a mistake to provide the exact post link. Giving links to main job portals of the official website of the organization is not enough as the job portal may contain more than one advertisement it may not serve the purpose as the readers find it to locate the exact post hence we ask to provide the exact post URLs and not main job portal URL.

    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455528-bombay-high-court-receuitment-for-senior-system-officer-system-officer
    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455197-gpsc-recruitment-for-lecturers-senior-psychiatrist-and-more
    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455168-dlsa-dhenkanal-recruitment-for-the-post-of-jr-clerk-jr-clerk-cum-typist
    The above job posts were inadvertently rejected, now it stands approved keeping in mind the time and effort devoted by the author for making this job post
    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455139-dh-fws-cooch-behar-recruitment-for-various-posts-under-nhm-nuhm
    The source provided for the above job post seems to not an official website it is a private job portal providing jobs from government organizations hence the job post was rejected
    https://www.indiastudychannel.com/jobs/455486-peb-bhopal-recruitment-for-sub-engineer
    The above job post was inadvertently approved in spite of the links from non-English sources provided, now stands it is rejected.

    More than one editor is reviewing the job posts, rectifications/responses can be made by any other editors.

  • #716061
    @Ravi Shankar: Hats off to you for clarification. Thanks.

    Following is the source of a job in three ways. Plz clarify if all these acceptable ?

    VPCI Recruitment 2020: 71 non-teaching vacancies on offer (Hindustan Times)

    1: https://www.hindustantimes.com/education/vpci-recruitment-2020-71-non-teaching-vacancies-on-offer-check-details/story-H94tbABlHymZ0BPA0uEyHP.html

    2: Hundustan Times, Delhi, 16th November ,2020

    3: https://www.hindustantimes.com

    @Saji Ganesh: Kudos to you. Thanks for your kind help.


  • Sign In to post your comments