You must Sign In to post a response.
  • Category: Miscellaneous

    Kerala government to grant menstrual leave to students

    The step taken by the education minister of the Kerala government is revolutionary in itself. Not everyone has this level of understanding. What it takes to understand such a crucial matter is empathy. Few people have the ability to recognize the mental and physical pressure on girls during the menstrual cycle. Also in a country like India, the situations she has to face in her daily life demand rest during such phases where she is not allowed to cook or stay in another room and too much involvement is also not expected from her. I think this initiative should be applied in universities of other states also, even in other fields too and not confined to these educational institutions.

    What are your perspectives on this initiative?
  • #768847
    That's a good decision by the Kerala government and I feel many other states may also think of implementing the same after some time. The same type of step was first announced by the Cochin University of Science and Technology (CUSAT) last week and this prompted the Kerala government to come to a decision in this regard. There are some organizations in India that grant menstrual leave to their employees though there are many who engage in debates questioning its viability. Many girls and women undergo physical as well as mental discomfort to some extent during their periods which affects their daily activities. To avoid this, it is always better to take a break during such times and I welcome this initiative by the Kerala government.

    In a populous country like India, the word menstruation is still taboo in many places and a large section of the female population is unable to maintain proper hygiene during their periods. Proper steps must be taken to alter the situation and participation of all from various walks of life is required to bring in the desired change.

    Sankalan

    "Life is easier when you enjoy what you do"

  • #768849
    Menstrual cycle is the part of life of a woman and is to be given due concern by all. Generally in the families during that time they are isolated from the family activities for those few days though in modern times many of the families are not observing this very seriously and women are working after taking the necessary precautions in this regard.
    Giving the women leave during such times is definitely a good gesture. This can be applied on the nationwide level also.
    Only thing is that if women themselves feel that such a leave is not required and they can work during those days also by using the modern facilities then management will have to consider that also.

    Knowledge is power.

  • #768850
    I read in in ladies magazine that 'ladies are concerned weak with reference to the monthly period and pregnancy. If proper facilities available in work places and institutions, it is not necessary to them to have isolated rest'. These words are given with base of freedom. But nobody thinks the bodily inconvenience happens to them in such time. Moreover no ladies including doctors are not caring the health disorder facing by them if there is no adequate rest to them in the two times.
    Welcoming this move by Kerala Government.

  • #768853
    It is a perfect way to gain cheap publicity sacrificing the academic interest of girl-child. When girls and women all over the world are taking part in all activities including sports during menstrual period, what is the logic behind such ridiculous decision?

    Further, what would the Government do if a girl demands postponement of Board examination for herself during her period days? Will the Government of Kerala postpone the examination for such students?

    This is a ridiculous decision. All progressive Malayalees must come out against such nonsensical diktat.

    (a) Those who have forgotten Noakhali, how can they protest Sandeshkhali?
    (b) Have no fear of perfection - you'll never reach it. ---------- Salvador Dali

  • #768855
    I don't say it is a bad decision. But every month three days leave means the students may have to think as they may not be able to catch up with the progress in lessons that is taking place during their absence. I think this leave is optional only and no rule that they have to take leave definitely. Students who have some problem during that time may opt for the leave but not every month . So it is the necessity of the individual that decides.
    We need give that much importance to that. But there is a chance of misuse. For other necessities they may use this leave. But definitely it is good for ladies who will have some pain and other issues during this period. So the chance given by the education department of Kerala should be used judiciously by the girl students based on their requirement.

    drrao
    always confident

  • #768857
    Though the Kerala Government has taken an initiative for the safety of girl- child allowing them leave for the menstrual period. This might have been taken keeping in view of their psychological changes in their behaviours due to hormonal changes. We must accept this fact this is the natural cycles with which which ladies are facing every month lasting for four to five days.
    However not all ladies require such leaves since majority of ladies in the current time don't face any psychological disorders during this stage and hence it should not be made compulsory for females joining their schools and colleges.

  • #768860
    Yes I am agree with the authors those are saying there is no need to make it mandatory because not everyone needs such a separate leave for it like somtimes it is our work or study material which divert ourselves from pain.

  • #768869
    My first response is to quote the Biblical verse, “Father, forgive them, for they do not know what they are doing." (Frankly the present people know well what they are doing and what they can gain from)

    The irony and hypocrisy of our people(especially the so-called liberal intelligentsia and the equality-promising Leftists) that I see, makes me wonder how easily these people make fools of us. I am not at all able to digest.

    It was these same people who were ridiculing and calling orthodox and uncivilized the earlier generation and (some still following) the practice of practically giving' home leave of 3 days' for the women by keeping them out of kitchen cooking jobs, doing poojas etc. The explanation that the tradition of keeping them 'out' (of daily works at home and avoidable outside travel )was actually intended to give them real rest, was pooh-poohed as male chauvinistic, caste-ist, barbaric and against gender equality.

    Again, it was the same people who clamoured for allowing menstruating women to temples, especially Sabarimala. One self-claimed 'swami' was preaching that women can enter temples even during menses days. Mind you, he is a solid leftist supporter of the present Kerala LDF.

    Now the same people are asking and even chest-beating about the menstrual leave!!! What an irony! What a hypocrisy! Where is the sense of gender neutrality adamancy which they strongly advocated for gender-neutral uniform in schools?

    Let these people understand the traditional wisdom and stand that physically and psychologically God or nature has made men and women differently. Nature or God has a real purpose for that. Hence there will be; (and should be;) differences in behaviour, food habits, certain capacities, responses, tolerances and treatment of men and women.

    The talk of gender equality while giving women all kinds of one-sided favour and reservations but giving equal salary and wages, is just an eye wash and blatant hypocrisy. It is nothing but vote-collection politics.
    I say it is for women to understand and expose this hypocrisy and double stand of these opportunistic exploiter people in real life.

    Those who are familiar with the many many cases of women abuse of various types reported in Malayalam and Kerala media can understand that the culprits are a good number from the same people or parties which outwardly stand for women's protection and women's rights. Some of those who were arrested or charge-sheeted (many are roaming free uncaught due to political and financial clout) were in the forefront of women empowerment renaissance programmes. What an irony, self-proclaimed protectors becoming predators!!

    I don't know whether to laugh or cry. Real equality, right and empowerment of women is actually by giving them preferential treatment, respect and regard as a women. That was there in our country till a couple of decades back. The neo-liberalists and hypocrite-gende- neutralists came and spoiled that and now they are trying to 're-discover'' it in some other way, but haphazard and half-baked way.

    It will be honest and open if they better admit their past adamant wrongs and declare that our country's past glorious tradition was correct and scientific. We 'Bharathvaasis' people are magnanimous enough to forgive you.

    PS: 1.I would like to see how the safety napkin manufacturers respond to this as it was they who were claiming and ensuring safe normal three days with their napkins. Now they will face business slump due to menstrual leave coming everywhere.
    2.Who can ensure that the menstrual leave facility is used as intended and not misused as many other women favoured facilities?

  • #768877
    I fully agree with Venkiteswaran Sir. I also tried to explain the hypocrisy of the present Kerala Government in my previous response. This State Government, on the one hand, tries to belittle the tradition of Hindus, and at the same time, takes impractical measures to keep its vote bank happy.

    I again reiterate my question: What would the Government do if a girl/some girls demands/demand postponement of Board examination for herself/themselves during period days? Will the Government of Kerala postpone the Board examination for such students?

    I request all to examine any such proposal threadbare and only then give their opinion. Any progressive and emancipated lady from any country who takes part in all activities during these five days would laugh at such proposal.

    (a) Those who have forgotten Noakhali, how can they protest Sandeshkhali?
    (b) Have no fear of perfection - you'll never reach it. ---------- Salvador Dali

  • #768894
    I think only CUSAT (Cochin University of Science and Technology) has passed an order in this regard and the Kerala government is only considering extension of this facility to other universities and subsequently to schools also.

    I think the analytical response by Venkiteswaran sir is reasonable and balanced though the question is not whether the initiative is by the left or the right but whether it is necessary or practical. At a time when women groups have been claiming that menstruation is a part of women's life and is just a natural process as any other physical requirements, the need for introducing this kind of a facility is not understood. It is not a condition that has popped up from the blue. While it is a fact that there may be some women who face mental and physical issues during their periods, there is no necessity to make menstrual leave a right for all women. I don't think it is a well thought of decision or even proposal. The reference by Venkiteswaran sir to the olden days when women used to be confined to one room is worth noticing.

    I am yet to understand why this proposal has been restricted to students alone. What about the working women and others who, as Partha said, is engaged in different chores in different fields for almost five to six days in a week?

    It is interesting to note that groups and individuals who are vehemently voicing their concerns over gender equality has either remained silent or have hailed the proposal.

    'Educating the mind without educating the heart is no education at all'.
    -Aristotle

  • #768978
    This special leave for women is for three days in a month. That means thirty days in an academic year. The students' loss is a month's class. How are they making it up?
    Another doubt is about the lady teachers. Are they too eligible for this special leave?

    tmsankaran


  • Sign In to post your comments