You must Sign In to post a response.
  • Category: Admissions

    20 Lakh students appeared in NEET exam and seats 170870

    I was thinking how unfair is educational system in India. Yesterday my dauther appearped for NEET exam and I was looking for the data of students online.

    Found more than 20 lakhs students appearing NEET examination all over India and going to struggle to get admission in medical as seats would be just approx 170870. And that too divided into various quota.

    Feeling not fair to the future of these candidates who would not able to get the seats even after scoring high in NEET.
  • #772970
    Geeta, let me, at the outset, wish your daughter all the best! Coming to the point, do you think that the number of seats should be increased? Why? Why should we be so concerned or worried about our kids becoming Engineers or Doctors? There are so many professions open to them and they should be able to have the choice.

    Appearing for NEET or clearing the exam or getting admission need not be considered to be the end of the road.

    'Educating the mind without educating the heart is no education at all'.
    -Aristotle

  • #772973
    Let us not be frustrated with this point that our wards could not show their better performance in the NEET. The author has definitely provided the very relevant details how the seats of different streams are filled up finally on the basis of merits. The successful students for the said test is inclusive of all successful candidates such as MBBS, BAMS , BHMS and for the diploma courses of Lab technicians, X - Ray technicians, Radiologists, Ophthalmologist etc.
    At the first outset, the candidates and even their parents might be disappointed if their wards could not secure seats for the MBBS courses. They are not going to compromise for any seat other than MBBS courses.
    They ignore the prospects of other courses but we have seen how other candidates having secured seats in other streams are far far better in terms of their incomes and prospects in the practical life. Hence we need to have thorough introspections of all the included courses of this scheme.

  • #772974
    This is not the case just with medical seats. Even engineering and management streams with IITs and top B-schools respectively, have the same issue. Every institute will naturally have a limited intake and students have to compete for those. Those who are determined to enter a particular stream should not get overwhelmed by the Stats. Just study and appear, and, more importantly, always keep Plan B and Plan C ready, for alternative streams. As Saji indicated, both parents and students should stop being obsessed with just one particular stream.

    Best of luck Geeta for your daughter's goals.

    When you make a commitment, you create hope. When you keep a commitment you create trust! ~ John C. Maxwell

  • #772977
    We are seeing competition everywhere. Jobs are fewer, and seats in educational institutes are fewer. The aspirants are more. This is seen in almost all fields.
    I don't know whether it is fair or not. But one thing is sure that people with merit are suffering. That is why we see many people trying to go abroad and study medical courses.
    Somewhere I read that the ratio of doctors and the population in India is not healthy and we require more doctors. At the same doctors prefer to stay in cities only. So in rural areas, we will not find many doctors. So I agree that there should be more medical colleges and government should insist that doctors should work in Rural areas also.
    There are many other courses like B V Sc, BAMS. BHMS, etc, and students can opt for those courses.
    Hope your daughter did well in the examination and wish that she should get a seat in MBBS in a good college.

    drrao
    always confident

  • #772981
    Geeta, wish your daughter all the best! You have given some statistics in the post and also tried to relate them to the education system in our country which according to you is not fair. Can you please co-relate the statistics and the unjust education system in the country? Also, do suggest what may be a fair education system.
    Sankalan

    "Life is easier when you enjoy what you do"

  • #772985
    1. At the outset, I wish Geeta Madam's daughter all the very best.

    2. Now, let me say something different. Checking the data provided by Geeta Madam (20 lakh candidates against 1,70,870 seats), I find that NEET is almost a cakewalk compared to Government recruitment examinations. Here, 170870 seats and 20 lakh candidates mean more than 5.85% candidates will find themselves successful, whereas in any Central Government recruitment examination, the success percentage is always less than 1%. So, those who prepare for Government competitive examinations, will say that NEET is a cakewalk, although this is not true.

    3. Now, let me be more serious. Why such terrible type of competition? Limited opportunities for medical/engineering is one reason, But another reason is inability of the guardians (most of them) to consider other alternatives, which may be more prestigious in the long run. A specific example. 99% of the students who take Biology in X+II level go for NEET. If they get selected, they will get MBBS degree after five years. Further studies at MD/MS-level is ten times more tough at the admission stage. But, in the major cities, who give importance on MBBS degree nowadays? All want MD/MS degree-holders for treatment. Even after knowing all these, no guardians ask their Biology-studying children to try for Genetics at Post-Graduation level. I do know that a PG degree in Genetics is far more prestigious and professionally satisfying than a plain and simple MBBS degree. Similarly, nowadays, studying Psychology has become very prestigious and professionally satisfying. But, do the guardians even know about these alternatives?

    This issue must be discussed in greater details by serious and senior (regular) members.

    (a) Those who have forgotten Noakhali, how can they protest Sandeshkhali?
    (b) Have no fear of perfection - you'll never reach it. ---------- Salvador Dali

  • #772989
    Our population is a big challenge for us. Whatever the examination there will be a great rush for appearing in them. Whether it is an engineering exam or MBBS exam or UPSC railways or post office or combined bank exam, everywhere a large number of candidates appear. Even many good candidates don't get success in their attempts. This is an alarming situation that despite having so many resources in our country we are not able to give admission to the candidates and what to talk about giving them jobs where there is still tougher competition.
    At the same time, new opportunities are emerging in the job markets and many certificates, diplomas, and skill courses are there which can help a student to make a career and earn a livelihood. I think we have to change our mindset in that respect if we want to make an alternate career.

    Knowledge is power.

  • #772992
    I was reading some data on 1 doctor per 1000 people in various countries. And surprisingly discovered that India has just 0.7 doctors per 1000 people. That is really not a good situation for any country. This is very far from the other countries.

    Hence the need of more and more qualified and expert doctors in India. On the other hand, I could not find India in the list of first 50 countries with this data which was for 2020.

    I think health ministry has taken big leap for opening new medical colleges and need loads of medical colleges in future in truly affordable fee. Else like pandemic few doctors and nurse would run the whole hospital, and no one will ask their life except tagging them as "warriors".

    Arvind
    "Education is the passport to the future, for tomorrow belongs to those who prepare for it today." - Malcolm X

  • #772996
    The feedback report in newspaper was that the questions were not that tough and students felt relatively comfortable.

    I concur with some observation by Partha comparing with certain other tests. I had appeared for some popular Pan-India tests and exams during my days as a fresher of searching a job.
    The competition was really tough as most candidates took the test seriously and there was mostly self study and no separate coaching. Those were days when unemployment of educated youth was quite high. Hence there was large and tough competition. But as I had(and many others) prepared with focus and a strong goal and adamant will I/we could pass the written exams generally well. But many candidate lost at the group discussion round or interview as exposure was lacking.
    I can proudly say that I got my job(s) only by passing the highly competitive tests and preparing and waiting for months for the procedure to complete.

  • #773189
    The situation you described raises valid concerns about the fairness of the educational system in India, specifically regarding the NEET exam and the limited number of available seats. With over 20 lakhs students appearing for the exam and only approximately 1,70,870 seats, it is clear that the competition is intense, and many deserving candidates may not be able to secure admission despite scoring well.
    This imbalance between supply and demand creates a significant challenge for students who have worked hard to excel in their studies and qualify for medical education. It can be disheartening for them and their families to see their efforts not translate into the desired outcomes.
    Efforts should be made to address this issue and ensure a more equitable distribution of seats. Increasing the number of available seats, expanding medical infrastructure, and investing in educational resources are important steps to consider. Additionally, a review of the quota system and its impact on access to medical seats could help make the process more transparent and inclusive.

  • #773198
    Thank you everyone who replied to this post. Good to see various prospects on this NEET. Some point even I agree with but still thinking of those who are doing hard work in their studies and dropping after the results due to admissions in medical colleges which is not so good.
    Learn one more language and you will feed your brain the top nutrition!
    - Geeta


  • Sign In to post your comments