You must Sign In to post a response.
  • Category: Miscellaneous

    Why are gated communities becoming very formal?

    Life in gated communities is often preferred by middle class individuals. Be it Bangalore, Chennai, Mumbai or New Delhi, certain things seem to be very common.

    There are Associations in each gated community. There are some rules and regulations. In the huge ones, there is a big club house, where one is told,booze parties are common as well. There are ladies clubs in many a gated community.

    Yet, there are complaints that most do not even know those living on the same floor. Not much of interactions at any level. The senior citizens often go all out of the way to make friends,but the younger generations have no time for them, even in their own families. I recently heard one family where the same IPL match between CSK and MI, which CSK won, was watched in two different bedrooms --one where the senior citizens are holed up, since they will not tolerate the loud clapping of their grandchildren!;

    Why is this going on? Is this a problem only with metros? I do get to live a few days together in such gated communities in Bangalore and Chennai only. In our small town, there is a gated community of only independent houses and people do know each other very well. The ration rice is rather subdued and it is an unpolluted atmosphere in a semi-urban setting.

    Members who have had totally better and very humane experiences in gated communities may please share their own views.
  • #779258
    I have seen many families having separate TVs in their bedrooms and one common TV in the hall. Some people can afford and they go for items separately. Different aged people will have different likes and accordingly, they will spend their time.
    There is a feeling in the people that gated communities are safe and that is true also. There will be restrictions for others to enter in the community. All the inmates should follow the rules of the association. If somebody goes out by locking their house also there will not be any problem. So families who can afford independent houses are going for duplex houses in these gated communities. It all depends on how much money one can afford. In Hyderabad also we see many gated communities that have apartments, independent houses, duplex houses and bungalows. These will be costing nothing less than a crore for the smallest apartment.

    drrao
    always confident

  • #779266
    [Response removed by Admin. Read forum policies.]
    Phagu Mahato
    Success occurs when opportunity and preparation meet.

  • #779278
    ABSivakumar,

    It is not very clear from your post what you are trying to refer to as formal in the gated communities. Are you talking about the rules and regulations maintained there? Rules and regulations are there in every family and when a lot of people stay in any gated enclosure there are rules for them so that things can function smoothly. Traffic rules are there since everyone uses the common road. Likewise, when people are sharing a common gate and passage, though the apartments may be different, there must be certain rules and regulations one must follow so that others in the vicinity are not disturbed.

    You have described the younger generation having very little interaction with the seniors and it's a common trend everywhere and not limited to gated communities. If a couple of people anywhere remain self-immersed then they will have no time for others and will never show any interest in people living nearby. This issue is something that is creating a lot of problems everywhere. People are moving away from social interactions yet remaining active on social networking platforms.

    Sankalan

    "Life is easier when you enjoy what you do"

  • #779279
    Community living is a necessity for various reasons. It is a reality and necessity and has come to stay. Like with anything, community living also has its pros and cons. I have been living in gated apartment communities since the seventies till the first decade of 2k.
    As it is a microcosm of the society, it has also all the characteristics of the society of that time. I don't think gated communities are only of the middle class. The concept of classes is fast changing.

    In the present day, the income and earnings of people have changed. Loan facilities for housing have become easy, cheaper, and convenient. So many people are now able to afford to buy flats or villas in gated communities. Even the urban-suburban or village differences have vanished in this regard. We can see luxury apartments and gated communities even in interior villages. So now we cannot say that only so and so class people are in the gated communities. It is a mixture and microcosm reflection of the society in general.

    Now, coming to the stated point of "...Not much of interactions at any level.....the younger generations have no time .." it is not just specific to gated communities but is the feature of present generations and times. The present generation and times give more emphasis to individual space and freedom. They can be financially independent and can afford to live independently with very minimum interaction with others around them.

    In earlier times population was less, people's mobility was less, and affordability and facilities were less. So most people remained in the same village or town. At the maximum, they moved to the nearest town or city when needed. As the number of households and total number of people were less, and as they stayed bound in the same place, it was natural that most people knew each other pretty well.

    But in today's general urbanization pace, even a single multistoried apartment has 500 or 1000 people living there. This is less than the total population in a ward in a Panchayat. I was living in a gated apartment complex comprising eight apartments. Each apartment has seven floors and 3 wings. Each wing has 4 flats on each floor. So in my building, we had 28 flats. If there are at least 3 persons in each flat then it is 28x3 +84 in one wing. Thus for 3 Wings, it is 84x3+252 persons. But some flats had five or six people too. So what will be the total number of persons residing in the whole complex? It will be more than 2000 people as some buildings have more than 3 wings also. It is equal to a whole village or two or three wards in a Municipality. It is not possible to know all the people there in a short time.

    But such gated communities have periodical meetings, gatherings, and get-togethers to celebrate festivals, general body meetings, etc. So by and by over a period of time most residents come to know each other. As there need the resident's associations and friends clubs for the welfare and entertainment of the residents, and there are periodical elections and changes of the office bearers, after a few cycles of these, most residents become familiar and friends with one another.

    So as far as I am concerned, I have a favorable bias towards community living, especially gated communities. Yes, it has to be admitted that there also may be some who may not be that cooperative accommodating, and understanding. There may be some small nuisance creators. But in general, even they will have to follow gradually and conform to the overall atmosphere and needs.

    All said and done, with many attendant cons community living is more secure, convenient, and less worrisome.

  • #779280
    Gated communities are preferred by the people mainly for security reason and those who have interest in social life like forming a group of like minded families or persons within that gated society and having fun and frolic of their choices. For gregarious and social persons it is the right place to live. At the same time there are many persons living in these societies but not mixing well with others and that behaviour is not only limited to these societies but is prevalent everywhere in our country.
    I am afraid the author has presented the life in gated societies in a subdued and negative form but actually there is nothing like that.
    Depending on the facilities in the gated housing society, it charges maintenance charges every month from its members. Those who can afford it happily pay it because it takes care of so many things for which they need not to brother.

    Knowledge is power.

  • #779285
    Mr Bhattacharya Sir, the focus of the thread is on the highly formalized relationships. I have mentioned that many do not know people living on the same floor. Hence, the scope of interactions should be much more. I do not know the present situation. I lived in Mulund West, an area that actually came under Thane but often referred to as Mulund West. The people were so busy during week days, but during the weekends, the youngsters would interact with other residents and almost everyone would spend time only at home. They were quite helpful to each other and we're from all States, even in the same building.

    Today, Chennai is another Mumbai, but whenever am there, I get to meet people in gated communities who never know anything about their neighbors. I really do not understand why.

    Well, the positives like increased safety, the ladies club, and the facilities and so on, have also been mentioned in my thread. We should perhaps increase interaction between people in such gated communities. Regarding the generation gap, perhaps the rat race is becoming even more acute in every city and the gated communities possibly have a greater share of the negative aspects of relationships between the old and the new being played out.

  • #779292
    In big cities, many people never know much about their neighbours and they meet very rarely or may not even meet. This is not because of any specific reason. Time constraints may be one of the reasons. These days in Hyderabad we see many apartments where many families are staying. But I doubt very much, about their interaction with the families in the neighbouring apartment.
    I can't agree with the other that negative aspects of relationships between old and new are more in gated communities. I think a proper study should be done by interacting with a minimum number of families is required before making some inferences. Sample size and sampling method play an important role in such surveys, I think. This is just my idea and I am not differing with the views of the authors. However, an elaborate study is required to come out with such an understanding.

    drrao
    always confident


  • Sign In to post your comments