You must Sign In to post a response.
  • Category: IndiaStudyChannel.com

    On just concluded GD

    The recently closed GD thread was initiated on 04 Jun 2024 at 19:18 hrs. and closed after the last response post of 11 Jun 2024 posted at 08:20 hrs.

    There was no mention of last date or closing date in the GD announcement thread. (Or did it escape my notice?)

    The discussion had relevance only up to the formation of new government and the oath taking function thereof.- i.e. maximum up to 9th June 2024.

    I am not able to understand on what logic and basis the GD was allowed to continue even when it was almost clear that not much relevant responses are coming. After 08 Jun 2024 21:20 hrs. there were just three response posts -one each a day on 9th,10th and 11th.

    Was it an oversight or a conscious decision?

    Most active GD s had only three or fur days life and this was the general tradition and experience. I remember reading about some direct or implied guideline sometime earlier, but not able to race it.

    It was in such belief that I concluded my side discussion by 7th June night ,22.58 hrs. On 9th there was only one post-that by the GD initiator- cum-Lead Editor.

    On 10th morning itself, there was an editorial intervention by Lead Editor Jagdish Patro, giving a veiled hint that the GD has lived its life and become irrelevant. Patro had not been a participant in the GD. But still, the GD was allowed to continue one more day before locking.

    It can be interpreted as my mistake closing my discussion early on assumption when there was no precise mention of last date. But this is my feedback.
  • #780164
    Some interesting observations by Venkiteswaran in respect of the said forum thread.
    This was an open thread till members were able to contribute some new points in the matter. Time to time such pinned discussions are opened in ISC without any closing date. When the editors find that nothing new is being added then they as per their judgement lock it as such open threads also have an end one day.
    That is what I simply understand by the way that thread progressed and met its logical end.
    It was in the nature of GD but not an officially announced one as a contest having a predefined end date.

    Knowledge is power.

  • #780166
    Most humbly and respectfully, I submit that this thread has never been formally declared a GD. Or, am I missing something?
    Billo Rani kahon to abhi jaan de doon: Oh dear Billo, if you ask, I will give my life

  • #780168
    Venkiteswaran Sir, it was not a GD at all! I, as the author of the thread, did try to get the contributing members, including you, to the track but failed. May be, some issues are best when not responded to. If you feel that pertinent points were not discussed, I suggest you raise another thread wherein we can discuss the points, you feel we have missed out.
    'Educating the mind without educating the heart is no education at all'.
    -Aristotle

  • #780175
    As far as my knowledge goes and what I understand from the thread content that the thread is for discussing the recent parliament results. Why does the ruling party which is expected to hike in the seats get less number of seats? What are the thoughts of various members on this issue? Is it an indication that the people of the country are not interested in some of the policies and ways of the ruling party? The very idea is to see that all the views will come in one place. No where it was mentioned as an active GD.
    These days the restriction of 10 days only for a thread is not there and authors are allowed to pull old threads and also discuss. As such there is no time limit for any thread. The same is the case for the present thread. As the thread is locked we can not post further. Probably no more to discuss about the impact of the results on the governance by the present government, the thread might have been locked.

    drrao
    always confident

  • #780213
    Thanks for the clarifications given by Saji Ganesh and other members.
    I stand corrected that the thread was not an official GD. The name of Lead Editors on the thread probably gave me the wrong assumption that it was an official GD. Definitely that is not an acceptable excuse, I admit. But I feel happy in giving some detailed thoughts on the topic.

    This thread may be locked now.


  • This thread is locked for new responses. Please post your comments and questions as a separate thread.
    If required, refer to the URL of this page in your new post.