SA-230 Audit Documentation (Revised)


Here in this article I have explained about AAS-3 or SA-230 Audit Documentation. What is documentation? What is the importance of working papers in audit? What are the provisions or guideline of ICAI relating to this standard? All are discussed in detail.

At the time of issuing audit report supportive evidences are required to obtain and that is called audit documentation. Audit documentation can be obtained during the audit or after completion of audit but before drafting audit report. The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India which is controlling authority in the field of auditing has issued auditing and assurance standard (SA 230) Audit Documentation to set uniformity in audit area. This standard is effective from April 1, 2009.

What is documentation?


Documentation are working papers which is prepared by the auditor for audit purpose and for his own use and not for client so that in future , if any case is filed against auditor for negligence of his duty then it can be provided as proof to other parties. It is maintained at three stage of audit work; audit planning, audit implementation and audit reporting. It should be provided that work of audit has been carried with planning and this can be proved by audit program and planning level working papers.

Types of working papers or file


Permanent audit file


It includes permanent information regards to the client or information which is not in nature to change year to year. This permanent information should be reviewed by auditor every year before starting work of audit for current year and same should be ask to client if any change is taken place. Details includes in the permanent audit file can be stated as follow.
  • Name, address and contact information of client.

  • Detail of legal and corporate structure of entity. If it is company then Memorandum of Association & Article of Association should kept which provide detail of legal existence of company.

  • Copies of legal documents, agreements and minutes which are directly or indirectly relevant to audit.

  • Record of study and verification of internal control system for accounting.

  • Copies of previous year audited financial statements.

  • Analysis of previous year ratios and trends.

  • Record of communication with previous auditor regarding to his appointment as auditor.

  • Notes to accounts which shows significant accounting policies followed by client.

  • Queries of observation of previous year audit.

  • Current audit file


    It includes current year audit information of queries, observations, justifications and confirmation from third parties and management. Current audit file will become helpful for next year audit work. It will include details of work done up to date, done by whom, time taken for completion, what areas are pending to verify?, queries found etc.

    Importance of audit working file


  • To understand nature, timing and audit process for complying with provision and applicability of statutory requirement.

  • To ensure result of routine audit procedure performed for vouching and verification. Whether any major query found and the same has been dealing properly or not?

  • Any matters arise during audit and conclusion or solution taken by managerial personnel. If any matter requires professional judgment of auditor then the same it can be available in audit file as proof.


  • Provision relating to working papers


  • Audit working papers are the property of auditor and not of management of the company so that auditor can to handover it to management if he wants. But management cannot compel him to handover because it is his personal working papers, company has not concern with the same. Here one more thing should be considered by the auditor that as working papers are his personal property, he cannot exercise right of lien on this papers.

  • As working papers are generated by auditor and it contains information about company which may include some sensitive information, so auditor should maintain confidentiality regarding to this papers and should not spread of leak any information of these. Even if there if not any specific provision regards to working papers confidentiality but ultimately AAS-1 Basic Principles of Governing Audit includes point of confidentiality which should maintain by auditor during the work of audit.

  • There is not any specific provision related that how many years working paper should be maintained. It is depends on the professional judgment to decide but the institute of chartered accountant of India has advised as far as possible it should be maintain for ten years and it can be maintain in bounded book form if it is comfortable.

  • Even if after completing or preparing and issuing final audit report, working papers should not delete because it can be needed at later stage. So it is always advisable to add working papers in the documents file of audit after every year on the completion of audit.

  • This is AAS-3 issued by The Institute of Chartered Accountant of India and exclusively for its members that are chartered accountants to follow while carrying process of audit. That means these AAS (Auditing and Assurance Standard) is for audit purpose and not required to follow by the management of the company nor accounting department because it is not any way relates to accounting principles, methods or compliance.


    Comments

    Guest Author: M. TPI20 Mar 2019

    Under SA-230, if an auditor resigns prior to completion of the audit and without providing an audit report, can the client (via a pre-audit contract) require him to return all confidential information? If the engagement ends without work product, can the client get their documents and confidential information back from the auditor?



  • Do not include your name, "with regards" etc in the comment. Write detailed comment, relevant to the topic.
  • No HTML formatting and links to other web sites are allowed.
  • This is a strictly moderated site. Absolutely no spam allowed.
  • Name:
    Email: